Fred Cogelow and Yudong Shen were the two jurors in this year’s Fine Arts judging who specifically included their emotional response to a work as one criterion used in their judging. Cogelow, first thing. Shen, third. Jurors in events such as The Minnesota State Fair are charged with a specific mission. They are expected to consider each piece in every category according to a set of specified standards.
Allen David Christian, Nude in The Key Of G First Place, Sculpture
Fred Cogelow , who cited gut reaction first in his Criteria Statement, awarded Allen David Christian’s sculpture First Place. It was definitely a crowd stopper when I was there, and while I was standing in front of the piece, one woman asked me to take her photograph standing behind it.
As I reflect on my own way of looking at art, or the world in general for that matter, it is my initial gut reaction that makes me stop to look in the first place. After I have stopped to look, I might go on to think further about other reasons to think about a particular work. Besides the sculpture, two paintings particularly caught my attention this year: Behind the Massage Parlor by Carl A Bretzke, which won the award for Best Landscape Painting by the Outdoor Painters of Minnesota, and SEED BODY: ON REACHING THE AGE OF MY MOTHER’S DEATH by Lois Imogen Rhomberg. In both cases, the title contributes to my experience.
Behind the Massage Parlor by Carl A Bretzke
Seed Body: On Reaching the Age of My Mother’s Death by Lois Imogen Rhomberg
First Place in that category, OIL, ACRYLIC, MIXED MEDIA, was awarded to Joan G. Fox, for her Mixed Media work, THE WAY FORWARD.
THE WAY FORWARD Joan G. Cox
I was confused at first, until I considered the title, and realized there really is no way into the work; the path follows around the outside edge. The center of the work does not provide any shape or clarity. Then I read juror, Lizzie Wortham’s Criteria Statement: Do the formal elements of the piece support the conceptual ideas being posed? and, Does the work propose a new direction or a valid point in the conversation of painting or is it derivative? Clearly, this work fills the bill. But, you’ve got to make me want to stop and look first, right?